“At companies, whether or not indoors or outdoor, masks are nonetheless required to be worn,” mentioned Los Angeles Public Well being Director Barbara Ferrer Thursday afternoon. Simply minutes earlier than, President Joe Biden delivered a unique message.
“I wish to be clear about what the CDC is saying and what the CDC shouldn’t be saying,” Biden mentioned throughout a speech marking the announcement. “The CDC is saying they’ve concluded that fully-vaccinated persons are at a really, very low threat of getting Covid-19. Due to this fact, if you happen to’ve been absolutely vaccinated, you not have to put on a masks. Let me repeat: If you’re absolutely vaccinated, you not have to put on a masks.”
Biden emphasised, “This suggestion holds true whether or not you’re inside or exterior.”
Gov. Gavin Newsom Says There Will Be No Outdoor Mask Mandate After June 15 In California – Updated
However the CDC hedged its announcement simply hours earlier than.
The CDC tweeted, “If you’re absolutely vaccinated in opposition to #COVID19, you’ll be able to resume actions with out sporting a masks or staying 6 ft aside, besides the place required by federal, state, native, tribal or territorial legal guidelines, incl. native enterprise and office steering.”
On additional inspection, the new CDC guidance doesn’t fully drop masks suggestions even for fully-vaccinated individuals. Face coverings are nonetheless beneficial in some settings — akin to aboard planes and buses or in crowded settings akin to hospitals.
Members of the media started mentioning the contradiction.
Faith Information Service Nationwide Reporter Jack Jenkins retweeted video of Biden’s speech with the next evaluation: “Based on the CDC, Biden’s assertion right here isn’t 100% right — there are nonetheless cases the place the company nonetheless recommends sporting masks even when vaccinated (e.g., on public transport, in airports, in nursing properties, and so forth).”
Observe: Based on the CDC, Biden’s assertion right here is not 100% right — there are nonetheless cases the place the company nonetheless recommends sporting masks even when vaccinated (e.g., on public transport, in airports, in nursing properties, and so forth). https://t.co/ZfPsWssuGE
— Jack Jenkins (@jackmjenkins) May 13, 2021
Jenkins was proper, and the discrepancy despatched ripples throughout the nation.
Earlier within the week, California Governor Gavin Newsom was strident in his assurance that masks have been going away for fully-vaccinated residents.
On Tuesday, Newsom was requested by a reporter if there could be a masks mandate after June 15. The usually-loquacious Newsom mentioned rapidly, “No.” He then enumerated just a few uncommon circumstances the place masks would nonetheless be wanted.
“Solely in these massively giant [indoor] settings the place individuals from world wide are convening & persons are mixing in actual dense areas. In any other case…no mandates,” he mentioned.
On Wednesday, the Governor appeared to take away the “massively giant” from his indoor prohibition, telling reporters, “For indoor actions we nonetheless may have, possible, some masks mandates. However the hope is these can be lifted sooner fairly than later.”
In Los Angeles on Thursday, Ferrer was requested repeatedly on a name with reporters whether or not the CDC steering ended all masks necessities for fully-vaccinated individuals.
“I feel there’s much more that obtained mentioned within the paperwork that obtained issued immediately,” she mentioned. “We’ll be speaking it beneath advisement. This was not pre-released to native well being departments.”
Ferrer famous that native well being officers might be extra strict that state and federal tips. She additionally mentioned that the state’s Division of Occupational Security and Well being, CalOSHA, won’t even meet till subsequent week to think about any modifications.
“As soon as the [unintelligible] board meets subsequent week we’ll hear extra. We can be aligning with CalOSHA,” mentioned Ferrer. One suggestion, she mentioned, was to not have everybody put on masks, however solely those that are unvaccinated.
“It might be simpler to ask that individual to masks and maintain their distance than asking everybody to masks and maintain their distance,” mentioned Ferrer.
Till the brand new guidelines are issued, reminded the L.A. Public Well being Director, “At companies, whether or not indoors or outdoor, masks are nonetheless required to be worn…Till there’s been a change in that, it’s actually necessary that we not bounce the gun and create an unintended consequence. Till that change, all workplaces could be out of compliance and topic to fines.”